Hightstown Criminal Defense Attorney

Hightstown is one of the smallest towns in Mercer County: the 2020 census counted 5,900 residents in about 1.3 square miles, completely surrounded by East Windsor Township. But Route 33, which doubles as County Routes 539 and 571, runs straight through its downtown, and U.S. Route 130 clips the northwest corner of the borough. Those roads bring far more drivers through Hightstown than live there, and that shows up on the court calendar.

Here is something many people do not realize until they read their notice: Hightstown cases are no longer heard in Hightstown. This page explains where the court actually sits, when Hightstown cases are called, which charges stay local and how to protect your record. To talk about your case, call Keith Oliver Criminal Law at (609) 789-0779.

Map of Mercer County, New Jersey, with Hightstown highlighted

Hightstown (highlighted) is surrounded by East Windsor Township. Map: Rcsprinter123, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

Hightstown Municipal Court at a Glance

  • Where court is held: the shared Robbinsville Township and Hightstown Borough Municipal Court, 2300 Route 33 (first floor), Robbinsville, NJ. Enter and exit through the rear parking lot.
  • Phone: (609) 259-3522. Because of high call volume you may reach voicemail; leave your summons or ticket number and the court says it will call back within 24 hours.
  • Fax: (609) 208-2563
  • Email: Robbinsville.MC@NJCourts.Gov
  • Office hours: 8:30 a.m. to 4 p.m., Monday through Friday, with shorter Friday hours in the summer

For Hightstown payment codes, call the court. Your notice controls, so double-check the date and location before you go.

Why Hightstown Cases Are Heard in Robbinsville

According to Robbinsville Township, its court began sharing services with Hightstown in 2011, after the remnants of Hurricane Irene flooded Hightstown’s court facilities. Robbinsville formally took over daily operations of the Hightstown Municipal Court in August 2019. Hightstown still has its own docket, but the cases are heard in Robbinsville’s courtroom by the shared court staff.

Hightstown matters are called on Wednesdays at 2 p.m. Most cases are handled in person, including DWI pleas, traffic trials and pretrial conferences, domestic violence-related criminal cases and cases that could mean jail or loss of license. To ask for a virtual resolution by Zoom, call the court.

Chart of shared Robbinsville and Hightstown court sessions: Robbinsville Tuesday 9:30 a.m. and 2nd and 4th Monday 1:30 p.m., Hightstown Wednesday 2 p.m.

Session times for the shared Robbinsville and Hightstown court, per Robbinsville Township.

Local Roads Where Hightstown Cases Start

Hightstown sits where several regional routes meet, so many of the people charged there are just passing through:

  • Route 33 (Main Street and Mercer Street). The main highway through the borough, shared with County Routes 539 and 571. It carries traffic between the Turnpike at Exit 8 and points east and west.
  • U.S. Route 130. A short stretch runs through the northwest corner of the borough.
  • The Route 133 Hightstown Bypass and the Turnpike. Both are just outside the borough line, in East Windsor. A stop there is usually an East Windsor Municipal Court case, not a Hightstown case.

That last point matters. The town line decides which court hears your case, and with Hightstown sitting inside East Windsor, it is easy to assume the wrong one. The court name printed on your ticket or complaint controls.

What Cases Does the Hightstown Municipal Court Hear?

The Hightstown docket covers the lower-level charges that arise inside the borough, including:

Municipal court trials are heard by a judge, not a jury. People who cannot afford a lawyer and face a real risk of jail or loss of license can ask for the municipal public defender.

Plea by Mail and Online Review

The shared court offers a plea-by-mail option for some matters and takes part in the state’s Online Municipal Case Resolution system for eligible moving violations, which lets a prosecutor review a ticket without a court appearance. These options suit routine traffic tickets. They are not designed for drug charges, DWI or anything that could lead to jail, and pleading by mail to the wrong charge can leave you with points or a record you did not need to take.

When a Hightstown Charge Goes to Trenton

A Hightstown arrest for an indictable crime is sent to the Mercer County Prosecutor’s Office. Prosecutors decide whether to seek an indictment in the Mercer County Superior Court in Trenton or to downgrade the charge and send it back to the local court.

Diagram showing which Hightstown NJ charges are heard in Hightstown Municipal Court and which go to Mercer County Superior Court in Trenton

Lower-level charges stay in Hightstown Municipal Court; indictable crimes go to Superior Court in Trenton.

A person who is held in custody will have a first appearance, and possibly a detention hearing, very quickly. Bring in a lawyer before that hearing if you can.

What Is at Stake: Penalties by Offense Level

The grade of the charge sets the ceiling on any sentence:

  • Petty disorderly persons offense: up to 30 days in jail and a $500 fine
  • Disorderly persons offense: up to 6 months in jail and a $1,000 fine
  • Fourth-degree crime: up to 18 months in prison
  • Third-degree crime: 3 to 5 years
  • Second-degree crime: 5 to 10 years
  • First-degree crime: 10 to 20 years, and longer for some offenses
Bar chart of maximum jail terms in New Jersey from petty disorderly persons offenses (30 days) to first-degree crimes (20 years)

Maximum jail exposure rises sharply once a charge is indictable.

Even when jail is unlikely, a conviction can follow you on background checks for years. License consequences come with DWI and many drug cases, and non-citizens need immigration advice before any plea.

Options for Keeping a Clean Record

Many Hightstown cases can be resolved without a conviction or with a much smaller one:

  • Conditional dismissal for many first-time disorderly and petty disorderly persons offenses
  • A conditional discharge for many first-time drug offenses
  • A plea to a lesser offense or an ordinance violation
  • Dismissal when the evidence or procedure falls short
  • Expungement once you are eligible

Diversion programs are generally one-time opportunities, so the choice of when to use one deserves a conversation with a lawyer.

How We Approach a Hightstown Case

We confirm where and when your case is actually scheduled, get the police reports and video, and look hard at the stop, the arrest and any testing. Then we work with the prosecutor toward a dismissal, a diversion program or a downgrade, and prepare for trial if needed. Because Hightstown cases are heard alongside Robbinsville’s, we know the courtroom and its procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is the Hightstown Municipal Court?

Hightstown cases are heard at the shared Robbinsville and Hightstown court, 2300 Route 33, Robbinsville. Use the rear parking lot entrance.

When are Hightstown cases heard?

Hightstown matters are called on Wednesdays at 2 p.m.

Can I appear by Zoom?

Most cases are in person. To request a virtual resolution, call the court at (609) 259-3522.

My stop was on the Hightstown Bypass. Which court has my case?

The Bypass is in East Windsor, so the case is usually in East Windsor Municipal Court. Check the court listed on your ticket.

Can a Hightstown conviction be expunged?

Often, yes. Many disorderly persons convictions can be expunged after a waiting period, and dismissed charges usually can be expunged right away.

Talk to a Mercer County Defense Attorney

Hightstown cases have an unusual setup, and showing up at the wrong building is an easy mistake. Keith Oliver Criminal Law defends people charged in Hightstown and across Mercer County. Call Keith Oliver Criminal Law at (609) 789-0779 or contact us online to talk about your case.