Theft charges in Mercer County range from a shoplifting complaint at Quaker Bridge Mall to an indictment for burglary, robbery or identity theft. Even a “minor” theft conviction can do lasting damage, because employers, landlords and licensing boards see theft as a crime of dishonesty, and for non-citizens it can carry immigration consequences. The good news is that many theft cases, especially first offenses, can be dismissed, downgraded or resolved through a diversion program.
The Mercer County theft and fraud defense lawyers at Keith Oliver Criminal Law represent clients in Trenton, Hamilton, Lawrence, Ewing, Princeton, West Windsor, East Windsor and throughout the county. Our Mercer County office is at 100 Horizon Center Boulevard in Hamilton. Call (609) 789-0779 for a free consultation, 24/7.
How New Jersey Grades Theft
Under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-2, most theft offenses are graded by the value of the property or services involved. The same value thresholds apply to shoplifting, theft by deception, receiving stolen property and theft of services. When the value is in dispute, the defense can often challenge the grading and keep a case out of Superior Court.
| Value involved | Grade | Where it is heard | Possible jail or prison | Maximum fine |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $200 | Disorderly persons offense | Municipal court | Up to 6 months | $1,000 |
| $200 to $500 | Fourth degree crime | Superior Court | Up to 18 months | $10,000 |
| $500 to $75,000 | Third degree crime | Superior Court | 3 to 5 years | $15,000 |
| $75,000 or more | Second degree crime | Superior Court | 5 to 10 years | $150,000 |
Certain thefts are graded higher regardless of value, such as theft of a firearm, a motor vehicle or property taken from the person of another. Indictable theft cases are prosecuted by the Mercer County Prosecutor’s Office and heard at the Mercer County Criminal Courthouse at 400 South Warren Street in Trenton.
Shoplifting in Mercer County
Mercer County has some of the busiest retail areas in central New Jersey, including Quaker Bridge Mall and the Mercer Mall in Lawrence, Hamilton Marketplace, and the stores along the Route 1 corridor in West Windsor and Princeton. As a result, shoplifting is one of the most common charges we see. Shoplifting cases from those stores are usually heard in the municipal court of the town where the store is located, such as the Lawrence or Hamilton Municipal Court.
Shoplifting under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-11 includes more than walking out with merchandise. It also covers concealing items, switching price tags, under-ringing at a register and moving items into other containers. New Jersey imposes mandatory penalties for shoplifting convictions:
- First conviction: at least 10 days of community service
- Second conviction: at least 15 days of community service
- Third or later conviction: a minimum of 90 days in jail
Stores may also send a separate civil demand letter asking for payment. That civil claim is not the same as the criminal case, and paying it does not make the charge go away. See our town pages for Lawrence shoplifting, West Windsor shoplifting, Princeton shoplifting and East Windsor shoplifting.
Mercer County Theft and Fraud Charges at a Glance
Use the filters to narrow the list, then click any charge to read our detailed guide. The meter on each card shows how serious the charge typically is, from disorderly persons offenses in municipal court to first degree crimes.
Other Theft and Fraud Charges We Defend
- Burglary (N.J.S.A. 2C:18-2): entering a structure or vehicle with the purpose to commit an offense inside. Usually a third degree crime, and second degree if the person is armed or causes bodily injury. See also car theft and car burglary.
- Robbery (N.J.S.A. 2C:15-1): theft involving force, injury or threats. Robbery is a second or first degree crime and is subject to the No Early Release Act, which requires serving 85 percent of the sentence before parole. Robbery convictions cannot be expunged.
- Carjacking: a first degree crime with severe mandatory prison terms.
- Identity theft (N.J.S.A. 2C:21-17): using another person’s identifying information to obtain a benefit, graded by the value involved and the number of victims.
- Credit card fraud (N.J.S.A. 2C:21-6) and passing bad checks.
- Forgery and money laundering.
- Theft by extortion, fencing and official misconduct.
Diversion Programs for Theft Charges
For many first offenders, the best outcome is a dismissal through a diversionary program:
- Conditional dismissal is available in municipal court for many disorderly persons offenses, including first-offense shoplifting, for people who have not previously used a diversion program. After a period of supervision, the charge is dismissed.
- Pretrial Intervention (PTI) is available for many indictable theft and fraud charges in Superior Court. Successful completion leads to dismissal of the charges.
- Downgrades and restitution. In appropriate cases, an indictable theft charge can be downgraded to a disorderly persons offense and sent back to municipal court, often with restitution to the victim.
After a dismissal, the record can usually be cleared through expungement.
How We Defend Theft Cases
- Intent. Theft requires the purpose to deprive the owner of property. Mistakes, misunderstandings at self-checkout and confusion over who owns property are real defenses.
- Value. Grading depends on value, and the State must prove it. Retail price, depreciation and aggregation of separate incidents are all open to challenge.
- Video and loss prevention evidence. We obtain store video and loss prevention reports to test what the store claims it saw.
- Statements and searches. Statements taken without proper warnings and searches without a lawful basis can be challenged.
- Identification. In burglary, robbery and fraud cases, the identification of the suspect is often the weakest part of the State’s case.
Students and Young Adults
With Princeton University, The College of New Jersey in Ewing and Rider University in Lawrence, Mercer County sees many theft, fake ID and underage drinking charges involving students. A conviction can affect scholarships, internships and graduate school applications, so these cases deserve careful handling and, where possible, a resolution that leaves no record.
What Happens After a Shoplifting Arrest
- Detention by store security. Store employees may detain a person they reasonably believe shoplifted and call the police.
- Summons. Police usually issue a complaint-summons with a municipal court date, and release the person at the scene or the station.
- Civil demand letter. Weeks later, the store or its law firm may send a letter demanding payment. This is separate from the criminal case.
- First appearance. At the municipal court, a lawyer can request discovery, including store video, and explore conditional dismissal or a downgrade.
- Resolution. Many first-offense cases end in conditional dismissal or another resolution that avoids a conviction.
Employee Theft and Embezzlement
Theft charges also arise in the workplace, from cash register shortages to allegations of embezzlement or misuse of company accounts. These cases often involve documents, audits and internal investigations, and they can carry large restitution claims. Early involvement of a lawyer can help manage the employer’s investigation, protect against self-incriminating statements and position the case for a favorable resolution.
Restitution and Immigration Consequences
In many theft cases, paying back the value of the property is an important part of a resolution. Restitution can support an application for PTI or a downgrade. For non-citizens, theft offenses are generally treated as crimes involving moral turpitude under immigration law, which can affect visas, green cards and naturalization. If you are not a U.S. citizen, tell your lawyer right away so the defense strategy accounts for immigration consequences.
Juvenile Theft Charges
When a minor is charged with shoplifting or another theft offense, the case is handled in the Family Part rather than municipal court. Juvenile cases offer more options for diversion and rehabilitation, and a good outcome can keep a young person’s record clean.
Receiving Stolen Property and Fencing
A person who buys, receives or keeps property knowing it was stolen, or believing it probably was, can be charged with receiving stolen property under N.J.S.A. 2C:20-7, graded by value like other thefts. These charges often arise from online marketplace purchases, pawn transactions and car parts. The State must prove what you knew or believed, and an unusually low price alone does not prove knowledge. Dealing in stolen property as a business can be charged as fencing, which is more serious.
Credit Card and Identity Fraud Investigations
Fraud cases often begin long before an arrest, with bank investigators, subpoenas for records and interviews by detectives. If you learn you are under investigation for credit card fraud, identity theft or bad checks, do not give a statement before talking to a lawyer. Early intervention can sometimes resolve a matter through restitution before charges are filed, or at least position the case for PTI.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is shoplifting a crime in New Jersey?
Shoplifting of items worth less than $200 is a disorderly persons offense heard in municipal court. Higher values are indictable crimes. Either way, a conviction carries mandatory community service and a record that shows up on background checks.
Can I avoid a record for a first shoplifting charge?
Often, yes. First offenders may be eligible for conditional dismissal in municipal court or PTI in Superior Court. Successful completion leads to a dismissal that can later be expunged.
Do I have to pay the store’s civil demand letter?
The civil demand is separate from the criminal case. Paying it does not dismiss the charge. Talk to a lawyer before responding.
What is the difference between theft and robbery?
Robbery is theft that involves force, injury or threats against a person. It is a much more serious crime, carries mandatory prison terms under the No Early Release Act, and cannot be expunged.
Where will my Mercer County theft case be heard?
Disorderly persons theft charges are heard in the municipal court where the offense occurred. Indictable charges are heard at the Mercer County Criminal Courthouse in Trenton. Our Mercer County Courthouse guide explains what to expect there.
Talk to a Mercer County Theft Defense Lawyer
Keith Oliver Criminal Law is part of Proetta & Oliver, LLC, and our attorneys focus only on criminal defense. Whether you are facing a shoplifting complaint in Lawrence or an indictment in Trenton, call (609) 789-0779 or contact us online for a free, confidential consultation.
For an overview of how criminal cases move through Mercer County’s courts, including the municipal courts, the Superior Court in Trenton and the towns we serve, visit our main Mercer County criminal defense lawyers page.